Conventional linear LNBF verses bullet LNBF

[IdealSAT]

I keep getting the question about what is better a bullet shape LNB or conventional LNBF. So, I compared the two LNBF's. I compared the GeoSat pro SL-1 Bullet (this is the only bullet LNBF that I know about) and a conventional linear LNBF. I will provably do a video on this topic in the future, but for now here are the findings of my test. I compared the DMX-521 LNBF 70 db gain typical, L.O. Freq 10750 from WSi. and the GeoSat pro SL-1 LNBF 55db gain typical, L.O. Freq 10750. Right of the bat the conventional design proved to have better gain (22% difference) just because of the extra capturing surface in front of the LNB? How do I know that? Well, I made a cup shape with my hand in front of the Geosat lnb and my db gain went up 6 db's. I went a step further and took aluminum foil and made a funnel (cone shape) that emulated the conventional LNB design (to be fair) and placed it in front of the geosat LNB. I got 12 db gain. That would take the Geosats gain from 55 db gain to 68 db. That was a 20% gain.

Test number 2: Using a 36" KU band dish, I measured quality and db strengths on a clear day. Test location North Idaho, azimuth 138.5 magn, elevation 31.0 degrees, skew -16.7. My Trimax SM-2200 reveled the following data with a pre-aligned satellite dish aimed at G-19 single LNBF. Test results: DMX-521= quality 89-91%, 89-90 db's
GeoSat LF-1= quality 67-70%, 70-86 db's the signal tended to jump around more.

Test number 3: Picture quality on both LNBF's was good! All the transponders looked good, no tiling, etc.

Test number 4: What remains? A good weather storm to run tests on stability for both LNBF's.

Living in North Idaho I have been using my dual output DMX-522 lnbf, same specs as the DMX-521 and I have yet to loose signal with up to 4 ft of snow, heavy rains, hail, etc. It has proven its quality in our book, but wait we have news! The brand new ESX-521 with 75db of again is now available, as soon as I get the new LNBF's I will run another test of some kind. Any suggestions?